Buying Guide

How to Choose a Mattress Topper

A mattress topper can transform your sleep for a fraction of the cost of a new mattress. Here's everything you need to know to choose the right one.

When Should You Get a Topper?

Your mattress is too firm and you want to add softness without replacing it

You have an older mattress (3–5 years) that's losing comfort but still has decent support

You're sleeping on a temporary mattress (guest room, dorm, rental) and need a comfort upgrade

You want to add cooling to a mattress that sleeps hot

You have back pain and want to test whether more or less cushioning helps before buying a new mattress

⚠️ When a topper won't help: If your mattress is sagging more than 1.5 inches or has lost its support core integrity, a topper will just conform to the sag. You need a new mattress.

Mattress Topper Types Compared

Memory Foam Toppers

The most popular type. Adds deep contouring and pressure relief to any mattress. Best for side sleepers and those with joint pain.

Thickness

2–4 inches

Price Range

$50–$250

Best For

Pressure relief, making a firm mattress softer

Pros

Excellent pressure relief
Great motion isolation
Affordable

Cons

Can sleep hot
Slow response time
Chemical off-gassing smell

Latex Toppers

Natural or synthetic latex. Adds bounce and cooling. More responsive than memory foam with a longer lifespan.

Thickness

2–3 inches

Price Range

$100–$400

Best For

Cooling, adding bounce, eco-conscious shoppers

Pros

Naturally cool
Bouncy and responsive
Very durable (5–10 years)
Hypoallergenic

Cons

More expensive
Less contouring than memory foam
Heavier

Feather / Down Toppers

Traditional plush layer. Adds a luxurious, pillowy feel without significantly changing support. Hotel-like comfort.

Thickness

2–4 inches

Price Range

$80–$300

Best For

Adding plushness, hotel-like luxury feel

Pros

Ultra-soft, luxurious feel
Lightweight
Good temperature regulation

Cons

No support improvement
Flattens over time
May trigger allergies
Requires fluffing

Wool Toppers

Natural temperature regulation — warm in winter, cool in summer. Naturally hypoallergenic and moisture-wicking.

Thickness

1–3 inches

Price Range

$100–$350

Best For

Year-round temperature regulation, allergy sufferers

Pros

Natural temp regulation
Moisture-wicking
Hypoallergenic
Eco-friendly

Cons

Minimal pressure relief
Can be expensive
Requires spot-cleaning only

Egg Crate / Convoluted Foam

Budget-friendly foam with a bumpy surface for airflow. Basic pressure relief for temporary use or tight budgets.

Thickness

1–3 inches

Price Range

$20–$80

Best For

Budget shoppers, temporary comfort improvement

Pros

Very affordable
Better airflow than flat foam
Lightweight

Cons

Least durable (1–2 years)
Minimal pressure relief
Can tear easily

How Thick Should Your Topper Be?

1–2 inches

Minor comfort adjustment. Adds a slight cushion without significantly changing mattress feel. Good for mattresses that are slightly too firm.

3 inches

The sweet spot for most people. Enough material to meaningfully change comfort and pressure relief. The most popular thickness.

4+ inches

Major transformation. Essentially creates a new sleep surface on top of your mattress. Best for very firm mattresses or temporary sleep situations.

Still Not Sure? Maybe It's Time for a New Mattress

If your mattress is 7+ years old or sagging, a topper is a band-aid. See our top-rated mattresses instead.

Best Mattresses 2026

Get price-drop alerts for the best mattress toppers

Get notified about notable manufacturer sales and price changes for the picks here.

No spam, no daily blasts. Unsubscribe in one click.

Never Miss a Deal

Get exclusive coupons and price drop alerts delivered to your inbox.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.

Hand-picked guides and reviews from our editorial team.