Compare Mattresses

Updated October 2026

Select up to 3 mattresses to line up the facts on record — construction, listed firmness, height, trial, warranty and Queen price. We don't crown a winner from scores we haven't measured.

Start Comparing

Pick 2–3 mattresses above, or use the Compare buttons in the catalogue below. You can also browse everything in the full catalogue table.

Browse & Compare Mattresses

Filter the catalogue by facts on record and add models to your comparison. Default order is alphabetical by brand — not a performance ranking. Sleep-position filters use our editorial firmness browsing ranges, a heuristic rather than verified fit.

SearchBrandConstructionQueen price on recordListed firmnessSleep position (heuristic)Sort

Include child-targeted & discontinued

Loading catalogue controls… · See the full catalogue table

Air-Pedic 800 Series Air-Pedic
Adjustable Airbed · 5.5/10 listed firmness
$2,599
No lab measurements
Airweave Advanced Mattress Airweave
Other · 9/10 listed firmness
$3,116
No lab measurements
Allswell Charles by Allswell Allswell
Hybrid · 6.5/10 listed firmness
$339
No lab measurements
Amerisleep AS1 Amerisleep
Memory Foam · 8/10 listed firmness
$1,049
No lab measurements
Amerisleep AS2 Amerisleep
Hybrid · 7/10 listed firmness
$1,299
No lab measurements
Amerisleep AS3 Amerisleep
Memory Foam · 5.5/10 listed firmness
$1,049
No lab measurements
Amerisleep AS4 Amerisleep
Hybrid · 4/10 listed firmness
$1,499
No lab measurements
Amerisleep AS5 Amerisleep
Hybrid · 3/10 listed firmness
$1,699
No lab measurements
Avocado Green Mattress Avocado
Hybrid · 7/10 listed firmness
$1,399
No lab measurements
Avocado Luxury Organic Avocado
Latex · 5/10 listed firmness
$3,599
No lab measurements
Awara Natural Hybrid Awara
Latex · 6.5/10 listed firmness
$999
No lab measurements
Bear Elite Hybrid Bear
Hybrid · 6/10 listed firmness
$1,290
No lab measurements
Bear Elite Ultra Hybrid Bear
Hybrid · 6.5/10 listed firmness
$1,977
No lab measurements
Beautyrest Black Beautyrest
Hybrid · 6.5/10 listed firmness
$2,199
No lab measurements
Beautyrest Black C-Class Beautyrest
Hybrid · 6/10 listed firmness
$2,999
No lab measurements
Beautyrest Black K-Class Beautyrest
Hybrid · 4/10 listed firmness
$3,499
No lab measurements
Beautyrest Black L-Class Beautyrest
Hybrid · 8/10 listed firmness
$2,799
No lab measurements
Beautyrest Core (Level One)Beautyrest
Innerspring · 6.5/10 listed firmness
$1,149
No lab measurements
Beautyrest World Class (Level Three)Beautyrest
Innerspring · 6/10 listed firmness
$1,399
No lab measurements
Beautyrest BeautySleep Dream Weaver Hybrid Beautyrest
Hybrid · 6/10 listed firmness
$1,099
No lab measurements
Big Fig Mattress Big Fig
Hybrid · 7/10 listed firmness
$1,499
No lab measurements
Birch Elite Natural Birch
Latex · 5/10 listed firmness
$2,812
No lab measurements
Birch Luxe Natural Birch
Latex · 6/10 listed firmness
$1,968
No lab measurements
Birch Natural Mattress Birch
Latex · 6.5/10 listed firmness
$1,249
No lab measurements
Bob's Discount Furniture Bob-O-Pedic Bob's Discount Furniture
Memory Foam · 5.5/10 listed firmness
$499
No lab measurements

Comparison Library

Popular Mattress Comparisons

The head-to-heads shoppers research most, each built from our scored review database.

Casper vs. NectarCompare the Casper Original and Nectar Memory Foam mattresses to find Casper vs. SaatvaCasper all-foam vs Saatva luxury innerspring — two different approache Casper vs. LeesaTwo popular all-foam mattresses with similar designs but subtle differ Casper vs. PurpleTraditional memory foam feel vs innovative Purple Grid technology — wh Casper vs. HelixOne-size-fits-all Casper vs customizable Helix — find out which approa DreamCloud vs. NectarBoth from the same parent company — hybrid luxury vs memory foam value DreamCloud vs. SaatvaTwo luxury hybrid mattresses compete for the title of best premium bed GhostBed vs. NectarCompare two value-oriented memory foam mattresses with different firmn Leesa vs. PurpleClassic foam comfort meets innovative grid technology in this mattress Loom & Leaf vs. TempurpedicPremium memory foam battle — Saatva's luxury foam option vs the memory Loom & Leaf vs. LeesaLuxury memory foam vs affordable foam comfort — which delivers better Nectar vs. LeesaTwo popular all-foam beds with different firmness levels and price poi Nectar vs. LaylaSingle-firmness Nectar vs flippable Layla — which memory foam bed wins Purple vs. NectarInnovative grid technology vs traditional memory foam — which provides Purple vs. GhostBedPremium innovation meets budget-friendly comfort in this foam mattress Purple vs. TempurpedicNew-age innovation vs legacy quality — two premium approaches to bette

Compare Brands

Brand-level breakdowns covering line-ups, pricing and policies.

Bear Mattress ComparisonCompare all Bear mattress models to find the best one for athletes and Birch Mattress ComparisonCompare Birch natural and organic mattress options for eco-conscious s Casper Mattress ComparisonCompare all Casper mattresses from the Original to the Wave Hybrid.Helix Mattress ComparisonFind the perfect Helix mattress for your sleep style with our complete DreamCloud Mattress ComparisonCompare DreamCloud's luxury hybrid mattress options.Leesa Mattress ComparisonCompare all Leesa mattress models from budget-friendly to luxury optio Nectar Mattress ComparisonCompare Nectar's memory foam and hybrid mattress options.Nectar Hybrid Mattress ComparisonCompare Nectar's hybrid mattress lineup for those who want coil suppor WinkBed Mattress ComparisonCompare all WinkBed models from the original to specialty options.

Compare Mattress Models

Model-vs-model pages generated from our scored review database.

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt vs Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-ProAdaptMemory Foam · Memory Foam Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-LUXEbreeze° vs Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-PRObreeze°Memory Foam · Memory Foam Hybrid Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-ProAdapt vs Saatva HDMemory Foam · Luxury Hybrid Saatva HD vs Big Fig MattressLuxury Hybrid · Hybrid Saatva HD vs Titan PlusLuxury Hybrid · Hybrid Beautyrest Black K-Class vs Beautyrest Black C-ClassHybrid (Pillow Top) · Hybrid Beautyrest Black L-Class vs Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-LuxeAdaptHybrid · Memory Foam Stearns & Foster Estate vs Beautyrest BlackLuxury Innerspring · Hybrid Sealy Posturepedic Plus vs Saatva ClassicHybrid · Innerspring Hybrid Sealy Posturepedic Plus vs Stearns & Foster EstateHybrid · Luxury Innerspring Serta iSeries Hybrid vs Beautyrest BlackHybrid · Hybrid Leesa Sapira Hybrid vs Helix Midnight LuxeHybrid · Hybrid Leesa Sapira Hybrid vs Leesa OriginalHybrid · All-Foam Nolah Evolution 15 vs Brooklyn Bedding Aurora LuxeHybrid · Hybrid Bear Elite Hybrid vs Brooklyn Bedding Aurora LuxeHybrid · Hybrid Amerisleep AS3 vs Casper OriginalMemory Foam · All-Foam

More Head-to-Heads

Every other matchup in the library, built from the same review database.

Simmons Escape No. 6 vs Simmons Escape No. 2Innerspring · Innerspring Simmons Escape No. 11 vs Simmons Escape No. 2Innerspring · Innerspring Simmons Escape No. 2 vs Beautyrest BlackInnerspring · Hybrid Beautyrest Core (Level One) vs Beautyrest BlackInnerspring · Hybrid Beautyrest World Class (Level Three) vs Beautyrest BlackInnerspring · Hybrid Beautyrest World Class (Level Three) vs Saatva ClassicInnerspring · Innerspring Hybrid Beautyrest Core (Level One) vs Sealy Posturepedic PlusInnerspring · Hybrid BeautySleep Dream Weaver Hybrid vs Serta Five Star MattressHybrid · Hybrid BeautySleep Dream Weaver Hybrid vs Beautyrest Core (Level One)Hybrid · Innerspring Serta iSeries NXG 3500 Hybrid vs Serta iSeries NXG 2500 HybridHybrid · Hybrid Serta iSeries NXG 2500 Hybrid vs Serta iSeries NXG 1500 Hybrid FirmHybrid · Hybrid Serta iSeries NXG 3500 Hybrid vs Serta iSeries NXG 3500 Medium FoamHybrid · Memory Foam Serta iSeries NXG 4500 Ultra Plush Foam vs Serta iSeries NXG 3500 Medium FoamMemory Foam · Memory Foam Serta Perfect Sleeper Hybrid vs Serta iSeries NXG 1500 Hybrid FirmHybrid · Hybrid Serta Perfect Sleeper X Quilted Hybrid Level Two vs Serta Perfect Sleeper X Quilted Hybrid Level OneHybrid · Hybrid Serta Perfect Sleeper Cascade Canyon vs Serta Perfect Sleeper Cascade Ridge Plush 12.5"Innerspring · Innerspring

Adjustable Base Comparisons

Head-to-heads for adjustable bases and smart bed systems.

Symphony Sleep ES600 vs. Ergomotion Quest 4.0Two mid-range adjustable bases with premium features — Symphony's mass Symphony Sleep ES700 vs. Reverie R650The ultimate luxury adjustable base showdown — smart home integration Symphony Sleep ES600 vs. Malouf S755Mid-range powerhouse vs. premium triple-motor base — does the Malouf's Ergomotion ErgoSportive vs. Symphony Sleep ES700Smart health-tracking adjustable base vs. luxury smart home base — bio Avocado Eco Adjustable Base vs. Symphony Sleep ES600Eco-friendly organic adjustable base vs. feature-packed mid-range base

Pillow Comparisons

Pillow head-to-heads, kept separate from our mattress testing.

Coop Original vs. Purple HarmonyAdjustable shredded foam fill vs Purple's GelFlex Grid — two of the mo Coop Original vs. Casper PillowTwo top-rated all-position pillows — Coop's adjustable fill vs Casper'Tempur-Pedic Cloud vs. Coop OriginalPremium one-piece TEMPUR foam vs budget-friendly adjustable shredded f Purple Harmony vs. Casper PillowPurple's innovative GelFlex Grid pillow vs Casper's pillow-in-pillow d Avocado Green vs. Coop OriginalCertified organic latex pillow vs adjustable shredded foam — eco-frien Eli & Elm vs. Coop OriginalEli & Elm's U-shaped shoulder cutout design vs Coop's versatile adjust Technogel vs. Tempur-Pedic PillowItalian-engineered gel technology vs proprietary TEMPUR foam — two pre MedCline vs. Helix Wedge PillowMedical-grade acid reflux system vs Helix's affordable wedge pillow — Pillow Cube Pro vs. Coop OriginalPillow Cube's square side-sleeper design vs Coop's versatile adjustabl

Still Not Sure?

Take our sleep quiz to narrow the list by position and preference.

Take the Sleep Quiz