Side-by-side mattress testing · 144+ comparisons published
Updated September 2026
Category
Serta Five Star Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
Comfort
Not lab tested
9.1/10
Support
Not lab tested
9.4/10
Cooling
Not lab tested
9/10
Edge Support
Not lab tested
9.1/10
Motion Isolation
Not lab tested
8.9/10
Durability
Not lab tested
9.2/10
Value
8.6/10
9.5/10
Blank cells mean that model has not completed our instrumented lab protocol, so we publish no measured score for it. We never estimate a number we have not recorded.
Quick Specs Comparison
Spec
Serta Five Star Mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
Price (Queen)
$519
$749
Type
Hybrid
Hybrid
Firmness
6/10
6/10
Height
Varies by comfort level
11.5 inches
Trial
120 nights
120 nights
Warranty
10 years
10 years
Shipping
Free shipping
Free shipping
Key Advantages
Why Choose Serta Five Star Mattress
- Free shipping in a box — no delivery scheduling
- Sold in multiple heights and feels
- Expands quickly enough to sleep on the first night
Why Choose Brooklyn Bedding Signature
- Three firmness options (Soft, Medium, Firm)
- Excellent value - factory direct pricing
- Great for back pain relief