Side-by-side mattress testing · 144+ comparisons published
Updated September 2026
Category
Puffy
Casper
Comfort
9.2/10
Not lab tested
Cooling
8.5/10
Not lab tested
Motion Isolation
9/10
Not lab tested
Edge Support
8.3/10
Not lab tested
Pressure Relief
9.2/10
Not lab tested
Value
8.4/10
8.8/10
Durability
8.7/10
Not lab tested
Blank cells mean that model has not completed our instrumented lab protocol, so we publish no measured score for it. We never estimate a number we have not recorded.
Quick Specs Comparison
Spec
Puffy
Casper
Price (Queen)
$1,549
$995
Type
Foam / Hybrid
Foam / Hybrid
Trial
365 nights
100 nights
Warranty
Lifetime
10 years
Manufacturer Specs Compared
Figures each brand publishes on its own product page. Values a brand does not publish show as "Not published".
| Spec | Puffy | Casper |
|---|---|---|
| Profile height | Not published | 11" |
| Layers published | Not published | 3 |
| Cover material | Not published | Not published |
| Coil count | Not published | Not published |
| Coil gauge | Not published | Not published |
| Zoning | Not published | Not published |
| Foam density | Not published | Not published |
| Fire barrier | Not published | Not published |
| Certifications | Not published | Not published |
| Made in | Not published | Not published |
| Queen dimensions | Not published | 60" W x 80" L x 11" H |
| Queen weight | Not published | 76 lbs |
Sources: Casper official page
Key Advantages
Why Choose Puffy
- Cloud-like plush feel appeals to comfort seekers
- Lifetime warranty included
- Stain-resistant removable cover
- Made in the USA
Why Choose Casper
- Zoned Support foam targets hips and shoulders
- Better responsiveness for position changes
- Wider retail availability for testing
- Snow cooling technology on premium models